Repair vs Replace: How to Decide for Any Device

Decision guide for phones, laptops, tablets & gaming consoles

Your device is broken. First question: fix it or buy a new one? The answer depends on several factors. This guide helps you make the financially smart choice.

The 50% Rule

If repair cost is less than 50% of replacement cost, repair it. If it's more than 70%, usually replace it. Between 50-70%? Consider your device age and brand.

Factor 1: Device Age

Under 3 years old: Almost always repair. Device still has value and performance.

3-5 years old: Repair if cost is reasonable. Consider OS support remaining.

6+ years old: Consider replacement. Aging battery, outdated software, security risks.

Factor 2: Extent of Damage

✓ REPAIR

  • Screen crack
  • Battery drain
  • Single component failure
  • Water damage (recent)

✗ REPLACE

  • Multiple system failures
  • Logic board damage
  • Frame/chassis broken
  • Old water damage

Factor 3: Repair vs Replacement Cost

Example 1: iPhone 14 with broken screen

Repair: $130 | Replacement: $800 | Decision: REPAIR (saves $670)

Example 2: 8-year-old MacBook with logic board failure

Repair: $700 | Replacement: $1,200+ | Decision: REPAIR IF under 60% replacement cost, otherwise REPLACE

Factor 4: Warranty & OS Support

Check if your device:

Special Case: Gaming Consoles (PS5, Xbox)

PS5 HDMI port repair: $150-250. New PS5: $500. Always repair. Game saves stay with the repaired console.

Repair Cost Calculator

Quick decision framework:

1. Estimate repair cost: Call 2-3 repair shops

2. Know replacement cost: Look up new device price

3. Calculate ratio: Repair / Replacement

Ratio under 50%: Definitely repair
Ratio 50-70%: Repair if device is under 4 years old
Ratio over 70%: Usually replace

Environmental & Ethical Angle

Repairing extends device life, reduces e-waste, and is better for the environment. When in doubt: repair = more sustainable.

Need help deciding? Find a trusted repair shop for a professional opinion on your device.